Personality vs Upbringing - So Far, Personality Wins
Jaimie on Nov 21st 2007
It is continually amazing to me how two kids who both have the same parents can be so different from one another. But in so many ways, CJ and Alexa are like night and day. Well, in every way except that they both preferred night over day…
CJ has always been my adventurer. He has never met a challenge he hasn’t wanted to tackle. He may be shy around new people, but new “things” he has no problem with. He was the one at gymnastics class climbing over the obstacle course and jumping in the foam pit before the teacher had even finished explaining what they were supposed to do. He’s the child who tried to, at 11 months, climb the curved ladder up the playground equipment and when he was too short to reach the next bar, wiggled himself up one of the edge supports (with anxious mommy standing right next to him with a hand he didn’t need under him at all times). He literally walked as soon as he could take a step, ran as soon as he could walk, and is a “do now, think later” type of child. He’ll build a tower of blocks as high as it will go until it falls down with no thought about how to make it stable enough to last, because he’ll just start building it again as soon as it falls.
Alexa on the other hand, she is much more reserved. Not that she lacks curiosity or drive, but she goes about it in a whole different manner. She thinks, and even in her 12 month old face, you can see her thinking and considering options before she crafts a plan of attack. When she builds a tower, she looks at the two pieces and figures out how to fit them together. Each piece builds upon the last. She still is not walking, because she doesn’t feel confident in letting go of the edge. You can see her consider it, and then she’ll drop back to crawling or go another direction instead of walking away from what she’s holding on to. I’m convinced that this point she won’t actually walk on her own until she does it accidentally. She’s always been a thinker - she spent much of her first year watching the world from the safety of mommy or daddy’s arms and content to see what what going on without getting involved in it.
That’s not the only way they differ. CJ was the child who needed no sleep. Or at least, it seemed that way to us. He woke up every few hours like clockwork, every night, for literally two years straight. Once in a while he would sleep through for a few nights, just enough for me to think that he was finally sleeping through the night, then he wouldn’t again. Two years is a long time. Amazingly enough, he is now at three a great sleeper who puts himself to sleep and stays asleep all night on his own. But I digress.
Alexa may love the nightlife as much as her brother did (they were both night owls and she still is) but when she goes to sleep, it is for the long haul. She strung longer stretches of sleep together at 1 month old than her brother did at 1 year old. And she’s always been that way. We didn’t do anything different with her than we did with CJ, and she naturally slept completely differently. She’s not always the perfect sleeper and she does naturally want to be awake much later than either her daddy or I prefer, but she generally does a lot better overnight than her brother did anywhere near her age.
Two kids with the same parents… two totally different personalities and really, habits in general. I wonder a lot about nature vs nurture and what effect our parenting really has on them. I guess we’ll see how similar yet different they become as they grow older.
If you enjoyed this post, make sure you subscribe to my RSS feed!
I vote for personality too! It seems my kids were born with it - they are so different.
I totally agree with the personality angle on this one. I have two daughters and like your two kids, mine are total opposites. You’d think that with them both being girls, same mommy and daddy, same house, really everything is much the same, that they would be similar in some ways. This is not true at all.
Eldest DD is the quiet thinker, like your Alexa. She has always been a watcher, not a doer. She eats like a bird, is shy and timid. She has always been wary of strangers and new experiences take her a few times for her to get used to. She was a great sleeper and slept through the night early. She was an easy baby/child.
My 10 month old is the adventurer. She is outgoing and afraid of nothing. She is LOUD!!! She eats like there will never be any food again. She loves people and will go to anyone. She was a horrible sleeper and would wake up every two hours all night long for 6 months at least. She just started sleeping in to 6:15 in the last 2 days. She was a HARD baby, but she is adorable and sweet and so many other things that make up for the horribleness that was her first 4 months of life. She had bad reflux so I don’t blame her, I blame the Reflux that made her hurt so bad that she would scream for hours apon hours.
But anyway like you said. Totally opposite children in every way. And I love it!! What fun would it be with two children who were exactly alike? It’s better to have them mix things up and at our house we never know what’s going to happen. It makes me wonder what our third child will be like? A combo of the girls or something new altogether. Only time will tell.
Isn’t it amazing how siblins can be so different? Mine practically look like twins yet they are night and day. LOL Thanks for sharing with the Carnival of SAHMs!
Nice post! I have complete opposites too…and you’re right, it’s quite amazing that they come from the same parents! lol!!
oh, btw, I’m here from the SAHM Carnival!
Thanks for coming to visit and thanks for including my post in the carnival! yay!